Blog

As the demand for eco-friendly materials rises, PBS (Polybutylene Succinate) and PLA (Polylactic Acid) have emerged as two of the most popular bioplastics. Both are biodegradable and derived from renewable resources, but they differ in properties, performance, and applications. This article will compare PBS and PLA to help you choose the best fit for your needs.

1. Overview of PBS vs PLA

1.1. What is PBS?

PBS, short for polybutylene succinate, is an aliphatic polyester that is attracting increasing attention due to the possibility of bio-based production and its balanced properties, enhanced processability, and excellent biodegradability. Thanks to its balance of durability and environmental friendliness, PBS is widely used in various industries, including packaging, agriculture, and textiles.

Polybutylene succinate (PBS)

Read more: PBS Plastic: Definitions and Applications You Should Know

1.2. What is PLA?

Polylactic acid, also known as PLA, is a thermoplastic monomer derived from renewable, organic sources such as corn starch or sugar cane. Using biomass resources makes PLA production different from most plastics, which are produced using fossil fuels through the distillation and polymerization of petroleum.

Despite the raw material differences, PLA can be produced using the same equipment as petrochemical plastics, making PLA manufacturing processes relatively cost efficient. PLA is the second most produced bioplastic (after thermoplastic starch) and has similar characteristics to polypropylene (PP), polyethylene (PE), or polystyrene (PS), as well as being biodegradable.

Polylactic acid (PLA)

Read more: How Is PLA Plastic Made?

2. Comparing Properties of PBS vs PLA

2.1. The Differences Between PBS vs PLA In Biodegradability

PBS (Polybutylene Succinate) is a biodegradable plastic that breaks down into CO2 and water through the action of enzymes and natural microorganisms after disposal. Its ability to decompose makes it a great choice for addressing environmental concerns.

The biodegradability of PBS depends on several factors, such as molecular weight, crystallinity, and chemical structure. One key factor is the presence of ester bonds in its structure, which are highly susceptible to bacterial attacks. This characteristic allows PBS to biodegrade effectively.

PLA is an entirely biodegradable polymer hailed as one of the most promising bio-based polymers because of its biocompatibility, biodegradability, high mechanical strength, nontoxicity, nonirritation, and processability.

PLA can be synthesized by low-energy processes, and it is independent of petroleum resources. Microorganisms can decompose waste PLA into H2O and CO2. After photosynthesis, CO2 and water are converted back into substances such as starch, which can be used as raw materials to resynthesize PLA, thereby realizing a carbon cycle process that does not pollute the environment.

2.2. The Differences Between PBS vs PLA In Molecular Structure

Polybutylene succinate (PBS) is a semi-crystalline polymer known for its versatile properties. Its molecular structure includes ester groups, which make it biodegradable. These ester groups degrade into smaller polymers when exposed to water, and the degradation rate increases with temperature. PBS has a chemical formula of –[O–(CH2)4–O–CO–(CH2)2–CO]N and can form two crystalline structures: α and β. The β structure typically occurs during material deformation. 

Polylactic acid (PLA) is a bioplastic made from repeating monomers having the chemical formula C3H4O2. Chemically, PLA is made from lactic acid molecules. The lactic acid is fermented from plant matter under precisely controlled conditions. The lactide dimer is produced by dehydrating lactic acid and then thermally degrading the lactic acid oligomers. The lactide is then polymerized using ring-opening polymerization in the presence of a catalyst.

The Differences Between PBS vs PLA In Molecular Structure

2.3. The Differences Between PBS vs PLA In Thermal Resistance

Polybutylene succinate (PBS) offers good thermal resistance, making it suitable for various applications. It has a melting point between 90–120°C and can be processed at temperatures ranging from 160°C to 200°C, similar to polyolefins.

PLA has poor heat resistance, with a heat deflection temperature (HDT) of 55–65 °C, which seriously limits the application range of PLA at higher temperatures, such as disposable heat-resistant products, utensils and other food packaging containers.

2.4. The Differences Between PBS vs PLA In Flexibility And Durability

PBS is known for its flexibility, toughness, and resistance to mechanical stress, making it highly durable under challenging conditions. Its semi-crystalline structure gives it excellent elongation properties, allowing it to withstand more wear and tear than PLA. Additionally, PBS maintains its mechanical properties across a wide temperature range, making it more versatile for long-term use.

On the other hand, PLA is less durable due to its brittle nature and lower resistance to impact and stress. While PLA performs well in controlled environments, such as packaging or disposable products, it is not ideal for durable applications. PLA’s brittleness can also make it prone to cracking or breaking under pressure.

3. Applications of PBS vs PLA

3.1. Applications of PBS

Polybutylene succinate (PBS) is a versatile biopolymer with a wide range of applications due to its biodegradability, biocompatibility, and strong mechanical properties. In the packaging industry, PBS is used to create food storage bags, wrapping films, cosmetic containers, and medical packaging. Its water resistance, gas barrier properties, and antibacterial abilities make it an eco-friendly alternative to traditional plastics, ensuring product preservation and safety. 

In agriculture, PBS is used in agricultural films to protect crops, fishing nets to reduce marine pollution, and garden products like biodegradable pots and trays. Its UV resistance and ability to decompose naturally make it ideal for sustainable farming.

In medicine, PBS is employed to manufacture syringes, catheters, and wound dressings, leveraging its biocompatibility to reduce infection risks. Additionally, PBS is used in toys, household goods, and construction materials, offering an eco-friendly option for various everyday and industrial products.

Applications of PBS

3.2. Applications of PLA

Polylactic acid (PLA) has diverse applications, making it a versatile and eco-friendly material. In the 3D printing industry, PLA is a popular choice due to its ease of use, low extrusion temperature, and compatibility with standard 3D printers. It is user-friendly, produces minimal odor, and can be sanded, painted, or combined with composites to achieve different properties.

In the medical field, PLA is used for biodegradable implants such as screws, anchors, and plates. These implants degrade into lactic acid over 6 months to 2 years, supporting the healing process by gradually transferring loads to the body.

For packaging, PLA is widely used in compostable materials like food packaging, disposable cups, bags, and tableware, offering an eco-friendly alternative to traditional plastics.

Additionally, as a fiber or nonwoven fabric, PLA is used in disposable clothing, feminine hygiene products, and nappies, emphasizing its sustainability and practicality in daily applications.

PLA Plastic Cups 

4. Which Plastic Should You Choose?

When deciding between PBS (Polybutylene Succinate) and PLA (Polylactic Acid), the choice depends largely on your specific application and performance requirements. PBS is ideal for applications that require high flexibility, durability, and thermal stability. It is commonly used in packaging, agriculture, and the medical industry due to its excellent water resistance, UV protection, and biodegradability. Additionally, PBS has a wide processing range, making it suitable for the manufacture of films, containers, and biodegradable agricultural products.

In contrast, PLA is preferred for lightweight and short-term use items, especially in 3D printing, food packaging, and disposable tableware. PLA is known for its rigidity and clarity, making it an excellent choice for compostable packaging and medical implants. However, it performs best in low-temperature environments because of its limited heat resistance.

5. Conclusion

In conclusion, PBS and PLA are two highly versatile and eco-friendly bioplastics, each offering unique properties and advantages. PBS excels in flexibility, durability, and thermal stability, making it suitable for long-term applications. On the other hand, PLA is favored for its rigidity, clarity, and ease of processing, making it ideal for compostable food packaging, disposable tableware, and 3D printing. 

Choosing between PBS and PLA depends on your specific needs, including the product's intended use, environmental conditions, and performance requirements. As environmental awareness grows, incorporating PBS and PLA into various industries can support greener practices and a more sustainable future.

6. About EuroPlas’ Bioplastics

EuroPlas offers cutting-edge bioplastic solutions through its BiONext brand, combining renewable materials like PHA, PLA, and PBAT to create sustainable, high-performance compounds. These bioplastics are sourced from natural elements such as corn and palm oil and fully biodegrade within 12 months into water, CO₂, and biomass, contributing to a circular lifecycle.

EuroPlas' BiONext

BiONext bioplastics boast excellent mechanical properties, including high hardness, impact resistance, and flexibility, meeting the diverse needs of industries like food packaging, agricultural films, and disposable cutlery. Their performance ensures both functionality and visual appeal for various applications.

By reducing reliance on fossil fuels and embracing renewable resources, EuroPlas’ BiONext bioplastics drive innovation in sustainable plastics. These eco-friendly materials play a pivotal role in advancing greener practices, setting a new standard for environmentally responsible solutions in the plastics industry while supporting the global shift toward sustainability.

For more information and samples, please contact us HERE!